Shayna

I ordered my usual size and they were too short and tight. Please bring back your old sizing. I'm afraid to try anything else.

The good news, I think, about the redesigned Mary Jane-now called Shayna-is that the back strap is fixed. All my other Mary Janes' back straps stretched out and don't stay up. The not so good news is that the front part of the shoe has changed-shorter and wider. A little bit froggy looking-not as slim as the old Mary Jane. Would love to have a combination of the old MJ front and the new Shayna fixed strap. Would also like to see the good old true navy blue come back rather than the bright navy. As always, tho, Crocs are the most comfy shoes ever!!!

My first pair of Crocs where the old style of the Shayna, when the back strap was movable. I worried that they would tear up fast because my feet are wide, I wore those for almost three years until I could feel every rock on the soles of my feet. I loved them and wanted another pair, but when I went to look for them Crocs no longer sold them the way I bought them first. So I tried the new version of the Shayna. In the older pair I wore a 7 so I tried the 7, but was too tight, so I put on an 8 and it was snug, but I figured that they would loosen up. They did but after just 3 months of wearing them, the shoe has tore up. Where the straps attach to the shoe has come off and took the side of the shoe with it. They are still very comfortable so I really hate that they tore up. I can't wear them because the strap flaps. I was REALLY hoping to have them for 3 years like the last ones., but sadly I was very wrong.

I love the updated Maryjane. I've had three of the previous older style (wore them out) and like the update of the stable back strap. If these stay as comfortable on my feet as the old ones, I'll wear them all the time (unless I'm wearing one of my other Crocs sandals)